Jeannie Babb Taylor: Got melamine? Formula-fed infants are at risk both at home and abroad
By Jeannie Babb Taylor
Thursday October 2, 2008 10:27:49am


As of this writing, approximately 53,000 Chinese babies have been treated for drinking toxic baby formula. The milk was tainted with melamine — the same chemical that killed more than 300 American cats and dogs in the recent Chinese pet food scandal. This time, greedy corporations are killing children. So far, four child deaths have been attributed the formula, while tens of thousands of children are still suffering from painful kidney stones or partial renal failure.

A similar atrocity occurred in Japan in 1955, when arsenic-tainted milk powder poisoned more than 12,000 newborns. Not until 1981 did the nation admit the extent of their baby milk atrocity — at least 600 deaths, more than 6,000 people still suffering 26 years later, and 624 people afflicted by severe mental retardation, developmental difficulties, and paralysis caused by brain damage.

This is not the first baby milk massacre in China, either. In 2004, 13 infants died from drinking counterfeit baby formula made from flour and water, and 170 others suffered serious malnutrition.

As in 2004, the current tragedy is no accident. Melamine (a substance used in plastic and fertilizer) was actually added to the baby formula as a way to increase corporate profits. Melamine mimics protein in some tests, so when the dairy farmers watered down the milk to cut costs, they added melamine to cover their tracks.

The investigation continues to unfold. So far Chinese authorities have detected melamine in 20% of the nation’s dairy milk. Twenty-two brands are affected. China initially claimed that the tainted milk was never exported beyond its borders. However, Chinese milk products have now been recalled from Bangladesh, Yemen, Gabon, Burundi and Myanmar.

Hong Kong regulators pulled Chinese milk, yogurt and ice cream off the market after finding that eight of 30 samples tested contained the poison. Hong Kong authorities found traces of melamine in two Nestle products — a follow-on formula for babies over a year old, and a type of milk used for catering. Nestle denies that their products are tainted, pointing out that Hong Kong recently made their melamine standards more stringent than U.S. and European standards.

The Chinese government is talking tough and taking action now, but the evidence indicates China knew about the poisoned milk weeks ago and chose not to act until the end of the Olympics and Paralympics.

Chinese authorities will have no mercy on their designated scapegoat. After all, their government responded to the pet food scandal by executing the head of China’s food and drug safety agency. Perhaps in this case a fitting punishment would be a steady diet of Sanlu baby formula.

As China faces another hit to its national image, parents around the world wonder, “Could this happen here?”

The answer is a resounding yes. Here in the U.S., the FDA has issued a warning against all Chinese-produced baby formula. Although it is illegal to import baby formula from China, officials cite examples of Chinese brands being sold in ethnic stores.

All formula-fed infants are at risk for various types of contamination, both intentional and accidental. Formula-feeding is not like breastfeeding, in which the milk passes directly from source to destination without risk of contamination, and the breast milk itself even contains substances that kill off foreign organisms like Salmonella.

Instead, formula-fed babies are exposed to contamination risks throughout production, canning, distribution, and even at home as the artificial milk is poured into a plastic bottle containing BPA, a substance known to be hazardous to humans since the 1930s. The bottle itself may also contain microorganisms, unless it has just been sterilized. Unfortunately, heat increases the release of BPA. Bottle-fed babies just cannot win.

The American formula industry issues product recalls every year. In May of this year, Abbott issued a recall because of product oxidation, which can cause nausea, vomiting and other gastrointestinal problems in infants. Past recalls have been issued by various U.S. formula manufacturers because of glass particles, unsanitary production conditions, Salmonella, incorrect mixing instructions, and other serious safety problems.

Intentional tampering has also occurred here in the United States. In 1995, the FDA seized 45,000 pounds of counterfeit infant formula. The milk trail led to 10 factories in eight states that were making bogus formula with counterfeit labels. The fake formula was being sold in supermarkets under brand names.

More often, formula fraud occurs after manufacturing. Fraudulent wholesalers offer retail stores stolen, damaged or re-labeled formula. In one instance, a man and wife simply bought cases of cheap formula off the shelf, relabeled it as an expensive dairy-free formula, and then returned it to the store. The couple netted thousands of dollars before being caught. Several allergic babies were harmed by drinking substances they could not tolerate.

The FDA offers parents suggestions for avoiding counterfeit formula: Know how your baby’s formula looks, smells and tastes. It is interesting that they fail to recognize the simplest safeguard of all: Avoid baby formula.

In all but the rarest cases, babies are much better off drinking mother’s milk. Breast milk is full of nutrients that provide lifelong benefits to the child. Just as important are the substances you won’t find in breast milk — melamine, arsenic and Salmonella, to name a few.

Jeannie Babb Taylor may be contacted at jeannie@babb.com, or you can leave a public comment on her blog at JeannieBabbTaylor.com.


[permalink]
Post a comment: You must be logged in order to comment.

 
toosavoter
Comments: 347
Joined: 06/26/2008
10/05/2008 12:48:50 PM
As the United States finds itself further and further in debt, it must turn to foreign investment in order to back our government's finances. Unfortunately, one of the countries with the largest cash reserve at this moment is China. We have become a nation beholden to China for our economic survival. We demand cheap consumer products, so Walmart forces its suppliers to move production overseas to low-cost countries like China in order to compete. It is very difficult for the US government to carry a big stick and punish China over human rights violations and product safety, when they hold so much of our economic future in their pocket. China has become an economic superpower in the world and we are giving them more power every year. At one time, they needed us more than we need them, but that tide has turned. We have supercharged their economic growth, and now it is self-sustaining.

As far as this latest melamine-tainted milk crisis is concerned, I think the Chinese mothers and fathers need to rise up and demand accountability from Beijing. When it was just dog food and toys sold in the US, they had no stake in consumer safety. Now that the problem has hit close to home, it is time for them to act. This is just another case of greed and fraud in order to make a profit.


 
CSS4Comm4
Comments: 159
Joined: 10/09/2006
10/03/2008 09:09:50 PM
I agree. Excellent article!

But, I wouldn't put it past Walmart to sell the cheapest candy or cheapest formula they can buy from China so their share-holders can share billions of dollars while they keep their employees on as low a pay scale as possible.

They didn't seem too concerned or too in a hurry to remove the tainted pet food a few years ago. You would think they would share some of those bllions and hire enough cashiers to keep the customer flow more efficient. Of course, they have to be careful not to hire too many or they might have a little spare time to organize a labor union.

 
voterb
Comments: 98
Joined: 12/01/2007
10/02/2008 04:34:28 PM
Great article.

Some contaminated products are now showing up in the US. Some Chinese candy containing milk products has been recalled. The contaminated candy is sold mostly in ethnic shops. I doubt we need to worry much about the candy from the grocery store or walmart.

<< < Prev - Next > >>